It all started in 2015, and it has taken almost eight years for Saifullah Khan, a former Yale student and an Afghan refugee whose family fled the Taliban, to see a glimmer of hope for justice.
We want to thank Claire Best for this Contribution – Please direct yours to Editor@GraniteGrok.com.
You can review our ‘Op-Ed Guidelines‘ on the FAQ Page.
This past week, on the anniversary of the introduction of the 1972 introduction of Title IX, the Connecticut Supreme Court published a ruling against Yale University and a Jane Doe who had claimed immunity in a defamation suit brought by Saifullah Khan following a Title IX sexual assault disciplinary procedure which Yale claimed was “quasi-judicial”: Jane Doe had claimed Saifullah Khan raped her and Yale took her at her word and sided with her against Khan without calling witnesses he had put forward in his defense of the accusations.
The Connecticut Supreme Court ruled that the Title IX disciplinary procedure which caused Saifullah Khan to be deprived of his Yale education was not “quasi-judicial” because it failed to offer Khan his due process rights which included, inter alia, the ability to cross-examine his accuser — something he had been granted in a criminal sexual assault trial stemming from allegations by the same Jane Doe. Khan was acquitted of all charges by a criminal jury, but Yale held its own standards, which it claimed were “quasi-judicial” and yet had no legal standing.
Fifteen women’s and victim’s rights non-profits, which included Legal Momentum, the National Women’s Law Center, Futures without Violence, the National Crime Victims’ Law Institute, Know Your IX, National Alliance to End Sexual Violence, wrote an amicus brief in support of Jane Doe’s immunity for making false statements.
Khan-v-Yale-et-al-amicus-brief-AS-FILED-6.17.22
The Connecticut Supreme Court rejected their amicus brief. The full list of organizations that supported Jane Doe and her false accusations is here:
- Chicago alliance against sexual exploitation
- Connecticut coalition against domestic violence
- Fierberg national law group
- Futures without violence
- Jewish women international
- Know your ix
- Legal Momentum
- National Alliance to end sexual violence
- National coalition against domestic violence
- National crime victim law institute
- National Network for victim recovery of DC
- National Network to end domestic violence
- National Women’s law center
- Sanctuary for Families
- Women’s Law Project
Several of these organizations had also supported Amber Heard, who was successfully sued by Johnny Depp for defamation in a civil suit in 2022. Amber Heard claimed she was a victim of domestic abuse and sexual violence in an Op-Ed written for her by the ACLU and published in the Washington Post in December 2018.
The ACLU then partnered with one of the organizations included in the list above — Know Your IX — to sue Trump Education Secretary Betsy DeVos. They didn’t think the due process in sexual assault cases on campus was appropriate. They lost the case, but campuses still didn’t fully embrace her new standards requiring due process. Joe Biden’s 2020 election campaign promised to revert to the 2011 unregulated standards. He believes those who believe in due process are like “Nazis marching on Charlottesville.”
These women’s and victims’ rights organizations have been fast and loose with their language — so much so that they had to refile their amicus brief to the Connecticut Supreme Court for Jane Doe in Khan v Yale because their first one stated that Khan “raped” Jane Doe.
Connecticut Supreme Court rejected that amicus brief outright since Khan had been acquitted of all charges, including rape, in a criminal trial. Facts haven’t mattered to these groups, and they toss the word “rape” around like cotton candy in Disneyland. One of the reasons they toss it around is because it is a word that draws sensationalist attention for # engagement which is always good for major brand advertisers/sponsors tied to them, such as L’Oreal (and its multiple global brands under it).
Now that Yale is facing a $110 million defamation suit and so is Jane Doe, perhaps these organizations will think before they support, encourage, or recruit the next Jane Doe or Amber Heard for their lucrative false accusation industry. They harm women’s credibility and agency. They do not help it.
Cancel culture on college campuses and in high schools and the denial of due process for Saifullah Khan at Yale are all connected, as is the censorship of media and social media and the use of Government-backed propaganda to create fake rape narratives (harming many real victims of sexual assault in the process).
The University of New Hampshire should be held accountable because it all started there:
Cancel culture on campus and Saifullah’s deprivation of his civil rights would not have happened if Vice President Joe Biden had not introduced an unregulated federal directive “Dear Colleague” Title IX letter at the University of New Hampshire on April 4, 2011.
This unregulated directive spawned Kangaroo Courts. “Ambassadors” and “influencers” (posing as journalists) were engaged by the White House & non-profit affiliates to promote propaganda and silence dissenters. The PR money was flowing to journalists at every major publication: New York Times, Boston Globe, Washington Post, Teen Vogue, Glamour Magazine, The Guardian, The Sun, The Daily Mail, BuzzFeed, and The Daily Beast, to name a few. NBC, CBS, and CNN especially were also partnered to promote the “rape culture” narrative. It was used to get women voters engaged and to the polls (for female Democrat candidates only, however).
UNH was providing guidelines to the White House that made preposterous biased assumptions using faulty statistics and propaganda.
The University of New Hampshire was in a strategic partnership with the White House “Not Alone” task force headed by Valerie Jarrett, President Obama’s Chief of Staff. But also involved were the Department of Education Office of Civil Rights, the Department of Justice Office of Violence Against Women, and the Department of Defense. All of whom have been silent on Larry Nassar, Jeffrey Epstein, Ghislaine Maxwell, and Hunter Biden.
The money flowed from the Department of Justice Office of Violence Against Women and others to non-profits working with political PR firms who, in turn, would help get journalists to place sensationalist and untrue tales of rape on campus in magazines and newspapers. The UN was part of it as well — Emma Watson was recruited as the ambassador to influence “the Harry Potter” generation.
It was nothing short of a profiteering and racketeering industry that boosted the ratings of young female Ivy League graduates such as Alexandra Brodsky with political or book publishing goals in their future.
Hopefully, with Saifullah Khan’s historic win in the Connecticut Supreme Court, victims’ rights activists who promote “Bystander” and “Know Your Power” training or who drink Brett Sokolow’s cool-aid will think twice before continuing with this or with the “Believe women” false accusation industry.
Yale and Jane Doe are facing a defamation suit in which Saifullah Khan is seeking $110 million for being labeled a rapist and denied the tools with which to defend himself.
Khan’s attorney Norm Pattis criticized Yale’s methods in a January 2019 blog post.
“There’s no doubt in my mind that the process Yale used to engage in its fact-finding was fatally flawed,” Pattis said in the post.
The University of New Hampshire’s Prevention Innovation Research Center was recognized for entrepreneurship with the creation of “Soteria Solutions” to teach “Bystander” and “Know Your Power” training. Lyn Schollett, JD of the NHCADSV, is on the board.
“Bystander” and “Know Your Power” training were heralded by the NHCADSV at Phillips Exeter Academy and St Paul’s School in New Hampshire.
Vanity Fair highlighted the failures of “Bystander” training in “Mr. Weber’s Confession.” The genius of the training -for which UNH received millions in federal grants to create — led to a retired school teacher being framed for a sexual assault that his “victim” said never happened.
For all the federal grants the University of New Hampshire has received to study sexual, domestic violence, and child abuse, it can’t even address problems of such on the home front both on its own campus and in its State Youth Detention Center.
It’s time the Office of Inspector General for the Department of Justice (who funded UNH’s flawed research and training), Department of Education, and Department of Defense (with whom RAINN is tied) take a hard look at the violations of constitutional rights that the University of New Hampshire in partnership with the Obama White House introduced on April 4, 2011, and which were used to influence not only campus disciplinary procedures but also police criminal procedures.
It’s also time for the New Hampshire Bar to question the New Hampshire Criminal Courts and Police and ask why it was ever appropriate for them to take instruction from Laura L Dunn, Joe Biden’s VIP guest to the launch of “Dear Colleague” in 2011 and a representative for the White House “Not Alone” task force.
Laura L Dunn instructed Concord Police at UNH, and Concord Police referred Chessy Prout (according to Chessy Prout’s “memoir” with an introduction by Congresswoman Ann Kuster — “I Have The Right To” and promoted by Dan Hill of hillimpact.com boasting his work in securing over $21 billion in Government contracts for his clients) — Owen Labrie’s accuser to Laura Dunn in Spring 2015, 5 months before his high profile criminal sexual assault trial.
Unlike Saifullah Khan’s journey through the sexual assault sham, there was no Title IX investigation to put in abeyance while the criminal procedure played out in Owen Labrie’s case, which started one year earlier than Khan’s in 2014:
Concord Police had told St Paul’s School to stay out of it, to not let Owen Labrie know he was being investigated. According to the trial transcript, they advised his mother and him that there was no need for him to have an attorney present while they questioned him. But they had already recommended Laura L Dunn of the White House “Not Alone” task force and affiliated non-profit SurvJustice to Chessy Prout before they even contacted Owen Labrie in June 2014. They’d taken their instruction from Laura L Dunn, a lackey for Vice President Joe Biden, and she brought with her media, journalists, and an entourage of victims advocates and civil attorneys ready to go after St Paul’s School’s money off the back of the trial.
I was so, so lucky that the detective who interviewed me while I was laying in a hospital bed had just gotten back from a conference where they had worked on how to talk to and interview survivors of sexual assault. That was pretty serendipitous. She connected us with a wonderful attorney and advocate named Laura Dunn, who, when the trial came around, basically held my hand.
(It should be noted that on her way to the hospital, Chessy Prout texted Owen Labrie to say that things were getting out of hand. She’d told her sister that she never said she’d been raped, and the police wrote that statement down. But the police detective told her not to worry about the details and to not discuss anything with anyone, including her mother, for the “integrity” of the investigation. There was none. The police detective lied on a sworn affidavit about the report from the SANE nurse and used that to get an arrest warrant for computer communications which she then selectively redacted and tampered with. Where did she learn all of this?)
Laura L Dunn has been extremely vocal about her belief that due process is not appropriate in campus sexual assault cases. So what was she doing spreading this belief to police and prosecutors as well for criminal procedures?
Laura L Dunn was promoting her own business as an ambulance-chasing attorney for “victims,” and she needed to shop for them, train them and train police & prosecutors for her own self-advancement, which went hand in hand with the victim’s rights groups who could also profiteer from this business. She publicly stated that she wanted to be “Gloria Allred big.”
“I’m always mad that we’re not bigger,” said Dunn, matter-of-factly. “I want to be Gloria Allred big. People know if your civil rights get violated, you go to the ACLU. I want people to know if you get raped, you go to SurvJustice.”
And she had Vice President Joe Biden, President Obama, his chief of staff Valerie Jarrett, the Department of Education Office of Civil Rights (Catherine Lhamon), and the Department of Justice Office of Violence Against Women (Lynn Rosenthal) behind her as well as her mentor: S. Daniel Carter.
Nobody cared that Laura L Dunn had lied about her own alleged sexual assault on NPR in 2010, which they finally corrected five years later in 2015.
On the board of SurvJustice with Laura L Dunn was Wagatwe Wanjuki — a social media influencer — and Meg Garvin of the National Crime Victims Law Institute, which featured Dunn as a “partner spotlight” in November 2014 — the same month she promoted the false Rolling Stone “A Rape on Campus” story which led to the defamation suit Eramo v Rolling Stone (featuring Dunn in Exhibit 15b).
New Hampshire (“First in the Nation,” “Live Free or Die”) police and prosecutors swallowed Laura L Dunn’s instruction hook, line, and sinker to undermine their own criminal trial procedures. There was a ton of money on offer to them for doing so. The coffers filled quickly: Merrimack County Attorney (later US Attorney for New Hampshire and now Federal Prosecutor Scott Murray) called New Hampshire v Owen Labrie “A Victory for Victim’s Rights.” He was awarded “Prosecutor of the Year.” The National Crime Victim’s Law Institute who supported the false accuser Jane Doe in the amicus brief against Saifullah Khan and rewarded Concord Police Detective Julie Curtin in the investigation of Owen Labrie for “justice for the victim.” The judge, Larry Smukler, also pronounced “justice for the victim”. He’d decided to ignore prosecutor and police misconduct which were blatantly evident in the trial transcript.
We should not have any public funds going towards flawed sexually biased programs at the University of New Hampshire or elsewhere, which are then used to target, frame, profiteer, and racketeer and deny the assumption of innocence, a constitutional right.
Sharyn Potter, Executive Director of UNH Prevention Innovation Research Center, doesn’t hide her gender bias: She lists herself as a “Professor of Women’s and Gender Studies University of New Hampshire.”
Title IX’s language below is crystal clear against such bias. What were the Department of Justice Office of Violence Against Women & Department of Education, White House “Not Alone” task force thinking, and why isn’t there a Senate inquiry into this?
“No person in the United States shall, on the basis of sex, be excluded from participation in, be denied the benefits of, or be subjected to discrimination under any education program or activity receiving Federal financial assistance.
| Claire Best
The post False Rape Accusers Beware: Defamation Suit Against Jane DOE & Yale University Can Proceed appeared first on Granite Grok.