Claudine Gay was celebrated as the first black woman president of Harvard. She is not the first black woman to have reached the giddy heights of leadership in the US however. Before she came along there were several notable ambitious and brilliant black women: Condoleezza Rice, Jennifer Rubin, Shirley Chisholm to name a few.
Claudine Gay has had a privileged education — the accusations of plagiarism raise the awkward question — what are the morals of a privileged education? She graduated from private prep school Phillips Exeter Academy in New Hampshire — the same school that Mark Zuckerberg once attended. He later went on to hack into Harvard’s computer system to steal photos of female students to line up alongside each other to judge who was “hot” and who was not for FaceMash, the precursor to Facebook.
President Obama (a Harvard graduate himself) became the “Facebook” president. His administration focused on college & high school students and how to manipulate them using social media and grants from the Department of Justice for movements that could be used for groupthink and activism for politics.
NH Senator Maggie Hassan’s husband, Tom Hassan, was principal of Phillips Exeter Academy when it was investigated for cover-ups of sexual assault in the middle of the Obama administration’s campus rape survivor “It’s On Us” recruitment frenzy. The NH Attorney General (who owed his position to then-Governor Maggie Hassan) declined to prosecute. Had he charged administrators at the school, one wonders if Maggie Hassan would have ever made it into the Senate at all? Her champions, who were also pushing the campus rape survivor narrative, Senator Jeanne Shaheen & Congresswoman Ann Kuster, were silent about the Hassans and the Exeter scandal.
Meanwhile, they were busy collecting federal grants for New Hampshire from the Department of Justice Office of Violence Against Women and promoting a privileged student (Chessy Prout) from St. Paul’s School as a “survivor” of “rape” by the son of “working class” parents (Owen Labrie). Labrie, by contrast, was a student on full scholarship who should have gone to Harvard (on a full scholarship) but was denied that privilege as a result of a political show trial from which New Hampshire and his recruited accuser made millions using his face as the image they wanted to portray white male privilege.
Defense attorneys asked Chessy Prout under cross-examination where she’d acquired the language she used for her “under oath” testimony. At one point, she admitted, “I try not to lie too much.” Government Affairs PR “expert” Daniel Hill of hillimpact.com came on board to promote her as a “survivor,” complete with contracts for ads with Target (of course). Wouldn’t want a movement without an opportunity to turn it into a multi-billion dollar retail industry, would they? Dan Hill preached the power of feminism at the World Economic Forum in Davos while advertising for unpaid interns.
Claudine Gay was a professor at Stanford University whose most recent President, Marc Tessier-Lavigne, resigned after a first-year student documented his use of falsified imagery in scientific research papers.
It is believed by some that the board of trustees for Stanford knew about the problems with Tessier-Lavigne’s research when he was hired as president. Was it the fact that he was from Pfizer that this was overlooked?
Liz Magill, who resigned as President of UPenn after her testimony in front of Congress a few weeks ago, was Dean of Stanford Law School before taking up her position as President of UPenn. Under her were Barbara Fried, Joseph Bankman, Pamela Karlan, and Michele Dauber, among others. All of these have had serious ethical violations exposed in the last couple of years.
Michele Dauber was behind the framing of 19-year-old Brock Turner and the interference with his sexual assault trial and sentencing to cause the recall of Judge Aaron Persky. A commemorative bench was put up on the site where his alleged digital penetration of 22-year-old Chanel Miller (a friend of Michele Dauber’s) took place. It included a quote from the celebrated “Emily Doe” victim impact statement, which NH Congresswoman Ann Kuster, ACLU Ambassador Amber Heard, and others read to audiences on Capital Hill and at awards shows in 2016. There’s just one slight issue — the Emily Doe quote on the bench at Stanford was very likely not written by Chanel Miller but by Michele Dauber herself or an activist working with her. Dauber had discovered — according to one of her public statements — that the issue of domestic & sexual violence brought women out to vote “in droves.” She was a Dem Caucus rep raising money for Hillary Clinton’s 2016 election and the midterms in 2018. The issue of potential plagiarism seems to have been dismissed by Stanford.
Ironically, integrity in research is also dismissed by Rebecca Richman Cohen, a Harvard lecturer who made the documentary “Recall Reframed” about the recall of Judge Persky in the wake of the Brock Turner trial. Cohen’s research for her documentary wouldn’t even qualify as minimal— a cursory Google search proves that statements made by interviewees in her film contradict their own original statements in previous media records.
When I questioned Rebecca Richman Cohen in a Q&A following an online screening of “Recall Reframed” it was clear that not only had she not done her research but that the film itself was an attempt to gloss over a gross abuse of the criminal justice system by a Stanford law professor who used the trial for Democratic party political advancement. Cohen tried to claim that Professor Dauber was not a “carceral feminist” contradicting Dauber’s own statements about managing to get California minimum sentencing increased for the Democratic party. Cohen apparently didn’t even look at her own University’s Law Review on the subject. So what value is Ms. Cohen as an expert on anything to any student at Harvard?
Feminist Scripts for Punishment
President Obama allegedly lobbied for Claudine Gay to be Harvard’s president. Penny Pritzker is in the spotlight for heading the Harvard Corporation’s decision to hire attorneys to threaten the New York post with a defamation suit before any research had been done to verify or refute the Post’s claims.
Claudine Gay is “Teflon” just like Michele Dauber at Stanford Law School. Obama’s “czar” in the Department of Justice Office of Violence Against Women, Lynn Rosenthal, did say in 2014 (at the Dartmouth College Sexual Assault Summit) that the administration focused on campuses in order to influence generations to come and she worked closely with Russlynn Ali, Dauber’s friend in the Department of Education. Russlynn Ali now works at XQ Institute which advertises “DEI” and “Reimagining Education”. Page 79 of 838 pages in a FOIA email dump obtained by K.C. Johnson (after he had to sue the DoE to get it) reads:
“Finally, you asked for a contact to work with you over the next couple of weeks to assist the State Department in the government’s efforts to support the Muslim community.”
The email is dated November 2nd, 2010 and was sent by a Sunil Mansukhani to a redacted name with a cc to Russlynn Ali, Richardo Soto and Lilian Dorka all with Government email addresses.
https://www.chronicle.com/article/were-making-the-same-title-ix-mistakes-again
Supporting the Muslim community but no other communities? Why did the Obama administration’s Department of Education ignore Title VI designed to prevent discrimination or promotion of one race or religion over another?
DEI might have worked as a calling card for Claudine Gay to fail her way upwards using other people’s work as a crutch to get her into the ivory towers of Stanford and Harvard. But if she plagiarized in her 1997 dissertation and it was approved by the examiners then it begs the question as to what really is the moral value of an “elite” education.
Shamus Khan, a professor at Columbia University, has made himself into an expert on “privilege”. He wrote a whole book on it: “Privilege- the making of an adolescent elite at St Paul’s School”. One of the comments from a buyer by the name of “Chekov is not Czech” on the Amazon page reads:
1.0 out of 5 stars Khan’s book is a single sentence of Bourdieu’s Distinction (i.e., n o t an original insight)
“What very few readers/researchers/Americans see when reading Khan’s book is that Khan has taken his theme/thesis/hypothesis/argument entirely out of Pierre Bourdieu’s famous work, Distinction (Harvard, 1984). Read Distinction, and then read Privilege as a nice “interview” of what Bourdieu is the master of (in fact, Bourdieu himself has many such “interviews” in Distinction, but simply a few pages long, not an entire book to be purchased. You could easily and simply read the book reviews that Khan has posted on his wordpress website (connected to his profession as Sociologist at Columbia U) to ‘understand’ the book, in conjunction with page 311 of Bourdieu’s Distinction (copied below). Bourdieu would have been very impressed by Khan’s posting the reviews of Privilege, from political left to political right (it’s truly admirable), for Bourdieu would have seen the social structure via the reviews, just as Bourdieu himself gives us a glimpse of in Distinction. However, hands down, and I would hope Khan would admit this readily: Bourdieu is the master; Khan is just a follower, an acolyte of sorts. Privilege, perhaps if it wasn’t the work of a 26 year old, might have been much better if it had just focused on Khan’s main theme, that is, meritocracy and its euphemized, misrecognizable American form (and function) in today’s America. Instead, he brought to bear all his unbearable U of Wisconsin gender and race seminar junk.”
Would Shamus Khan receive the millions of dollars in grants for his research papers if he hadn’t attended St. Paul’s School, had his book not been published by the Princeton University Press nor he ended up with a job at another of the Ivies, Columbia University? Unlikely. The US Department of Education’s Office of Civil Rights, treats him as some kind of guru in the campus sexual assault, privilege and DEI space. He has spent his life in academia not in the real world where the 99% don’t have the time or resources to pontificate on any of his ideological and flawed research.
American Prep Schools, Ivy Leagues, Stanford, MIT are among the most expensive educational institutions in the world. What exactly does a student get for their financial investment? Certainly not a moral compass nor accreditation in original & critical thought.
Activism-led education is an extortion racket and a disaster. When the cracks in the campus “survivor” & #MeToo movements started to show, these activist academics flocked to Critical Race Theory. When these didn’t work and the quacks Ibram X Kendi (what was wrong with Ibram Henry Rogers?) and Robin Diangelo (“White Fragility”) could no longer profiteer from their shams, DEI replaced CRT.
Shiny DEI office plaques were put up on campuses throughout the nation advertising their new quackery. More administrators were hired who were so adept at their jobs that they used AI to write support letters for students in shock after campus shootings in Michigan. One wasted a visiting 5th Circuit judge’s time with an “Is the Juice Worth the Squeeze?” diatribe about which Liz MaGill’s replacement as Dean at Stanford Law (Jenny Martinez) wrote an absurdly long apology. “Sorry” is too simple and too lowly for “academics”. “Ethics” would put them all out of a job and rightfully so. It would save students a ton in fees to cover administrative bloat too.
These academic institutions are the recruitment centers for Big Government, Big Tech, Big Law, Multi-national corporations — some of which have paid out between tens and hundreds of millions for unethical practices and violations of US federal laws: Enron, Goldman Sachs, JP Morgan come to mind. Cheating — whether it is for the the Enron Scandal, 1MDB scandal or for Jeffrey Epstein belongs to those who graduate from the nation’s so-called finest. Jeffrey Skilling who went to prison in the Enron Scandal is a graduate of Harvard Business School. Jamie Dimon lied about his knowledge of Jeffrey Epstein. He is also an alum of Harvard. Gary Gensler of the SEC has been keeping a low profile since his relationship with Sam Bankman-Fried received scrutiny. He is a graduate of UPenn. Joseph Bankman, a tax law professor at and graduate of Stanford Law School, “recruited” Daniel Friedberg of Ultimate Bet online Poker Ponzi scheme for Alameda Research. It is only when they get caught that they profess to have made unwitting mistakes. What is taught at the nation’s top high schools, law schools, business schools, in political science courses or at liberal arts colleges? How to get ahead as a cheat or “It’s not what you know but who you know”?
For those who didn’t make it into the school or college that would cost their families a life-time of savings just for the label, consider that Elvis Costello (“Brilliant Mistake”) never finished high school. According to Wikipedia:
“His mother told a journalist that, when Costello was 11 years old, his school entered him into a writing contest held by the Times of London intended for people aged 16 to 25, for which he won a prize. As he finished secondary school, he earned one A-level, in English, despite having made a firm decision to pursue a career in music a few months earlier and putting little effort into his final months of school.”
He thought he was the King of America
Where they pour Coca Cola just like vintage wine
Now I try hard not to become hysterical
But I’m not sure if I am laughing or crying
I wish that I could push a button
And talk in the past and not the present tense
And watch this hurtin’ feeling disappear
Like it was common sense
It was a fine idea at the time
Now it’s a brilliant mistake
She said that she was working for the ABC News
It was as much of the alphabet as she knew how to use
Her perfume was unspeakable
It lingered in the air
Like her artificial laughter
Her mementos of affairs
“Oh” I said “I see you know him”
“Isn’t that very fortunate for you”
And she showed me his calling card
He came third or fourth and there were more than one or two
He was a fine idea at the time
Now he’s a brilliant mistake
He thought he was the King of America
But it was just a boulevard of broken dreams
A trick they do with mirrors and with chemicals
The words of love in whispers
And the axe of love in screams
I wish that I could push a button
And talk in the past and not the present tense
And watch this lovin’ feeling disappear
Like it was common sense
I was a fine idea at the time
Now I’m a brilliant mistake
The Ivies and adjacent “Elite” Schools might consider offering a course in Ethics, Empathy, Inclusion, Brilliant Mistakes and High School Drop Outs. Would that be worth upwards of $70,000 a year for the privilege? No, but apparently a course in Taylor Swift is.
The post Claudine Gay, Plagiarism & the DEI Lie. appeared first on Granite Grok.